Department Stores Are Slowly Dying. Macy’s Massive Store Closures

January 7, 2016 | By | 8 Replies More

In a recent Money report (link), Macy’s is just days away from closing 40 of it’s stores.

In addition, the Cincinnati Enquirer has speculated that number of Macy’s store closures could jump to 200 if current shopping trends continue.

Frankly, I’m not surprised by these reports, and I honestly wouldn’t be surprised if in the next 5 years, middle market department stores like Macy’s, Sears, and JCPenney close up to 50% of their stores.

Here’s the issue.

I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again — if the retail shopping experience does not fundamentally change, many of the the physical retail chains, such as department stores, will be a thing of the past.

Case in Point

Over the recent holiday, I was in a situation where I was in immediate need of a specific outfit, and didn’t have the time to shop online and have it shipped to me.

With the realization that I had no other choice but to go to the nearest mall, and since I’m rather particular about the type of clothes I like to wear, I wanted to see if there was a way that I could streamline my shopping experience.

I started with a Google search, like “white stretch dress shirt near me” (I prefer my shirts and slacks with a little stretch in them)

The search resulted in some reasonable leads to products in department stores like JCPenney, Sears, and Macys that were available at certain malls not to far from me. But that’s where the convenience pretty much ended.

Once I was in the stores, the experience was closer to mass disorganized chaos than it was to anything else.

Lost In Store

How to find things in department stores

How do I quickly find what I’m looking for in a big store?

I’m in store, mobile in hand, with the product I think I want to look for. Now what?

Try to find the product myself, but I don’t know where to start. The store is fairly organized, but I just can’t figure out where in the store the item is.

Tried to find a store employee, but I probably could’ve watched a full-feature film faster than I could find someone to help me.

Finally find someone to help me, but they don’t know where the product I’m searching for is.

At last I find the product I was looking for, but it wasn’t what I expected, and now I have to start all over.  (I’m excluding the whole fitting room experience, which we’ll talk about some other time)

Now, visit department store #2. Repeat. Department store #3. Repeat. Etc.

Out of My Mind

I don’t know about you, but that just isn’t what I call a pleasant shopping experience.

I was so frustrated by the whole thing. Hours wasted, and yet still couldn’t find exactly what I was looking for.

It’s for this very reason that I’m turning more and more to shopping online.

A Better Retail Shopping Experience

I’ve pretty much laid it out in this article, but even that can be improved upon.

How about we take that concept a little further.

What I want is a mobile app that has a map of all the stores in a mall, the ability to search for products within all those stores by keywords/fabric content, and the ability to locate a product within the store itself using some simple coordinate system (A1, B7, etc.).

Then, when you find the item, you can use that same app to scan the item and read reviews about it.

If your size isn’t available on the floor, but it is stocked at the store, put in an electronic request to have your sized pulled from the back so you can try it on.

That item goes directly to the fitting room, and you walk up and it’s ready for you to try on.

Great, perfect fit — now let’s use the app or some kiosk at the store to do a self or streamlined checkout with your credit card, Apple Pay, Google Wallet (Android Pay), PayPal, etc.  No need to wait in any long line, or wait for a staff member to help you.

Wow, now wouldn’t that be nice?

Are Department Stores Dead?

Not quite yet.

There are still people who like the ritual of browsing around, taking their time, and looking for that perfect item.

Plus, there are always those times where we need something urgently and can’t wait to have the item shipped to us.

But, if the major department store chains (and the malls they reside in) don’t get their act together pretty quickly, automate, and make the physical shopping experience more streamlined, malls as we know them today may become retail wastelands.


Tags: , ,

Category: News, Personal

About the Author ()

Tug is the world's undershirt expert. He is also one of the most knowledgeable individuals on sweat management solutions, men's shapewear, grooming, and new fabric technologies. Got a question? Visit Tug's contact page and hit him up.

Comments (8)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Brandon


    I agree with you. I buy the majority of things online these days but still like going into “some” stores to buy things.

    I used to shop at Macy’s quite a bit, but like you said, there is some major disarray in a lot of stores, Old Navy is one of the worst.

    You see some stores like Marshalls, TJ Maxx, and Best Buy, constantly tweaking their layouts, their process and customer experience to adapt to the times.

    • Tug says:

      heya brandon — yeah, retail is imploding pretty quickly.

      department stores are shuddering, and experience-based (or medical) services are moving in.

      i don’t think marshalls or tj maxx have any immediate troubles, due to the unique value they provide to the consumer.

      it’ll be interesting to see what happens to best buy.

      if they can continue to innovate their in-store experience and service offering, they have the ability to survive the long-game.

  2. John R


    Quite frankly I can’t understand how most of them can stay open, visit one any day of the week other then the special time when people are out shopping in droves and maybe if your lucky there are a dozen people, other then the 3 or 4 sales people. We walked through Pennies to get into the mall proper and I think I saw 3 of 4 people. Sears tool area was the same a while back.

    One has to feel sorry for the staff and the store.

    John in SC WI

    • Tug says:

      heya john, thanks for sharing your thoughts!

      yeah, it must be tough for the staff to work for an employer that hasn’t figured out how to evolve fast enough to stay relevant.

      maybe those employees are ok just putting in their time so they can get their paycheck, but how in the world do you get them excited about their job?

      i don’t know what these department stores have tried to keep customers coming in, other than offering sales, but so far, nothing they’ve done seems to be working that well.

      i’ll be keeping my eye out for any innovations in the space and will be reporting here on my site.

      the evolution of physical retail is very intriguing to me.

  3. Chris H


    I live in a semi rural area that is close to a couple of towns, but not large enough to have the large department stores like Dillards, Macys. etc.

    There is a couple of smaller store chains close by but if I want the better stuff, I would have about hour and a half easy one way to get there.

    Largest town I live close to is somewhere around 10,000 population and is 9 miles down the road from me.

  4. Chris H


    Hey Tug, I could not agree with you more. Sore spot for me for sure about these stores.

    I do not think as many people are buying as they used to be, and quality is lower than it used to be with a higher price tag.

    I do most all my clothing shopping on line now as compared to several years back mainly because I do not have ready access unless I drive 2 hours one way. I used to do it though, but i find more of what i want on line and get tired of prowling around a bunch of stores wasting my time and energy to come up empty handed.

    Macys will not be the only ones with troubles, just wait and watch.

    With every thing climbing higher and higher in price but wages stagnating, these stores are going to be in serious trouble, especially in this economy.

    Health care ought to be booming though, with the prices that service costs.

Leave a Reply

I promise you'll enjoy reading the rest of this article. If you're not 100% satisfied, just unsubscribe at anytime. Sound good??
I promise you'll enjoy reading the rest of this article. If you're not 100% satisfied, just unsubscribe at anytime. Sound good??